The Atlanta Braves should indeed feel fortunate for not pursuing Willy Adames during the offseason, despite initial speculation linking the two parties. While Adames had an outstanding 2024 season, with career-highs in home runs (32), RBIs (112), and stolen bases (21), his potential fit with the Braves raised significant concerns on multiple fronts, including defense, financial implications, and overall roster balance.
Defensive Concerns
Adames had a mixed defensive season in 2024, with a Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) of -16 and 1 Outs Above Average (OAA). While these metrics indicate some capability, they are a notable step down compared to the Braves’ current shortstop, Orlando Arcia, who registered a solid 5 OAA and 0 DRS. Defense has been a cornerstone of the Braves’ strategy, and downgrading in this area could undermine the team’s overall performance, especially with their reliance on elite defensive play in crucial moments.
Offensive Upside and Drawbacks
Adames’ power at the plate is undeniable, as evidenced by his slugging numbers and high barrel percentage. However, his 25.1% strikeout rate and inconsistent contact remain concerns. While the Braves could benefit from his offensive production, they already boast a lineup rich in power hitters. Adding Adames might not have addressed their underlying need for greater offensive balance, particularly in high-pressure scenarios.
Financial Implications
Adames signed a massive seven-year, $182 million contract with the San Francisco Giants, carrying an average annual value of approximately $26 million. For the Braves, committing to such a substantial financial obligation would have restricted their flexibility in addressing other needs, including fortifying the starting rotation and bullpen. Additionally, the cost disparity between Adames and Arcia—who is set to earn just $2 million in 2025—made retaining Arcia a far more budget-friendly option.
Roster Implications
The Braves have long emphasized depth and versatility in their roster construction. Signing Adames would not only have pushed their payroll limits but might have also limited their ability to retain or acquire talent in other areas. With potential upgrades required in pitching and other positions, investing heavily in Adames could have created unnecessary constraints.
Looking Ahead
Instead of overspending on Adames, the Braves are better positioned to explore more cost-effective solutions at shortstop or to rely on Arcia while addressing other critical areas. This approach aligns with their historical emphasis on balanced spending and long-term success, rather than splurging on a single high-profile acquisition.
By avoiding the temptation to pursue Willy Adames, the Braves have maintained the financial and roster flexibility essential for sustaining their competitive edge in
the National League.
